GameFAQs is about to have a Video Game Character Popularity Contest. Nominations are open up till Tuesday May 27.
Visual Novels are considered video games on GameFAQs and I think it'd be pretty cool if VN characters got in.
Right now Archer from Fate/Stay Night, Rin Tezuka from Katawa Shoujo and Rance from Rance are in the database, meaning all 3 of a decent amount of support to get in. Since the contest is going to have 200+ characters there's a good chance those 3 (and possibly others you guys want) could get in!
I'm personally nominating Rena Ryuuguu from Higurashi since she's pre