-
Posts
2436 -
Joined
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Downloads
Everything posted by Gerard the Lone Wolf
-
There you go.
-
This is not exactly relevant to the point I was making back then, but to be clear, I did try out at least the common route of Euphoria last year, though I didn't continue since reading with MT doesn't suit my style, unlike Ixrec who didn't even read a single line from the game (the point that you conveniently overlook for your pathetic trolling). It is hilarious indeed. Apparently, you still fail to read properly and understood the context before replying. ..l.. Try again next time.
-
If you didn't quote me in this very thread, I wouldn't have asked you anything too. Also, if you didn't start with your ass long fanboy rant bullshit, if wouldn't have escalated. You are the stupid one, and you are the one who brought KnS discussion in here, as well as being a hypocrite. It was a partial tease for Kara and Radiant, but it is my very opinion for G-sen, so I did not dismissed it entirely. If you didn't reply like a fanboy, the discussion wouldn't have existed either. I might answer if you can ask question properly. Your memory is very bad. I've already said it was a joke for Radiant. lolol I've no obligation to answer this, but oh well. A heroine that became a side character in her own route is already bad enough, combined with "bad guy being a bad guy for the sake of being bad and I like to destroy thing because that's what I do” villain, it is already nauseating. Let's just stop at this before I go into Chihaya rant mode for the hundred times. When exactly did I talk about F/sn writing? At best we can talk about stories structures, plots creations, characters development, and so on. But not the craftsmanship of the words itself because the translation is bad.
-
Because everyone needs to read Umineko to know whether Lucia's route is good or not. lol You are doing it to Butler's too, so don't speak like a victim. VVVV lol You wrote that he "give his best" and cited Saihate. How can you be so sure he gives his best if you don't even read it? lol Because you clearly know what VN I've read and don't read, right? Granted, I did not read Kara no Shoujo, and that post is meant to be a joke to Radiant and is extremely hyperbole. As if ----> isn't clear enough as a hint that it should not be taken too seriously. However, yes, you did write bullshit. Please don't deny it. I've also already gave my reasoning for G-senjou, but if you disagree, you clearly didn't show it at that time because you said it doesn't matter and your opinion on it is much worse than mine. The translation is stiff and awkward at times, that is a fact. As I've stated in the very same thread you're calling me on. That is all.
-
Yes troll, this is what happens when a loppez read the first half of a conversation and discarded the other half. Like I've told you before, learn how to read before posting. lol I'll just say two things. 1) If you think Lucia's route is the worse in Rewrite, worse than, say, Chihaya's route for example, then you clearly don't know what good storytelling is. Simple. Yes, Lucia's route generally feels way too different from the rest of the other four heroine routes, but the thematic elements are nevertheless the closest to Akane/Moon/Terra, so it is, in a way, still linked to the overall themes even when the route is detached in the storyline and characterization. 2) You recited Saihate no Ima as an example of Romeo's in his best form. Could you explain a little bit more, please? What did he do in Saihate that he couldn't/didn't do in Rewrite? I am curious now. Edit: I guess I'll also add my little opinions here, just because. I'll say that Rewrite major storytelling flaw is that most of the routes are too different from each others, mostly due to the multiple writers’ shenanigans, and the structure of the story is a broken one because it forces the readers to sit through multiple long routes that range from best to cringe worthy, before you can even get to the true route, the best part of the story. I won't deny these flaws, though not everything is that detached either. But personally for me, even if each routes does not work together that well, the main plot itself, especially in the true route, is full with inventive idea and was well-written. The VN tackles a very heavy theme; it based largely around the themes of ecology, evolution, human relationship with the planet, eschatology, and causality (some of which you have to admit, is relatively unusual in the medium), which play a prominent factor for the main plot. The true route did a great job representing all of these ideas and themes together while tying the loose-ends imo. It was a very enjoyable experience. So yea, Rewrite does have flaws, but the the true routes are more than enough to compensate for it, at least for me.
-
I am not sure what exactly is these flaws you are talking about here, and neither can I find concrete criticisms in it. Simply saying something is bad without any examples is pretty shallows, in my opinion. (not that I'm not guilty of it in the past) I guess it would be better if you could elaborate on it.
-
Visual Novels Translation Status [10/13/2013]
Gerard the Lone Wolf replied to Ryu's topic in Eroge News
Toushin Toshi 2 is out. -
But this is not in real life. Likewise, not many readers would be willing to date a crazy yandere girl in real life either, or enjoyed hardcore rape like in Black Lilith, but in VN... Sometimes I just don't get real life comparison, tbh. Anyway, real life or not, if people don't like it, then they don't. Simple as that.
-
Visual Novels Translation Status [10/13/2013]
Gerard the Lone Wolf replied to Ryu's topic in Eroge News
Futsuu as QC Dundundun -
*sighed* Because I've too much time today, I guess I'll become Danganronpa and start pointing out the obvious. I'll try to keep this brief and short. Let's bullet point it so it's easier to read and understand. 1) If you actually love to write, then write, otherwise, don't. If you like your characters, see that they fulfill their little roles in the stages, otherwise, don't. 2) If it wasn't that obvious already, no one here gives a flying fuck about Comyu's partial patch or Grisaia's trial either for reasons too obvious to be spelled out, unless donkan. 3) Absolutely no one here welcomed OELVN, that's why no one ever played Katawa Shoujo. Hanako sucks. 4) loppez is absolutely right. I should go and delete all of my reviews. 5) I wonder how many people read the Starswirl demo and is making fun of it. 6) Good writing is important in Visual Novel. 7) I fail to keep this brief and short. That will be all. Edit: Shit, I did not refresh the page before posting.
-
Visual Novels Translation Status [10/13/2013]
Gerard the Lone Wolf replied to Ryu's topic in Eroge News
Translation group? What translation group? lol
