Jump to content

Higurashi no Naku Koro ni (+Kai) review by Harlequin


Recommended Posts

Higurashi no Naku Koro ni (+Kai)(Ni VNDB)

 

Hinamizawa.jpg

 

 

(PS2) Opening movie:

 

 

 

 

(Spoilers are all inside the spoiler box down at the bottom.)

 

(Wall of text detected!)

 

 

"Everything will be over... when the Higurashi cry."

 

 

This will be a double review of sorts, involving both Higurashi no Naku Koro ni, which I will call "Ni", as well as Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai, which I will call "Kai". Ni is the first part of the Higurashi series, consisting of question arcs 1-4 (arc = chapter/story, more or less), while Kai is the second part consisting of answer arcs 5-8. I will call the series in its entirety "Higurashi". Simple!

 

I would like to preface all of this by saying that I read Higurashi with all available patches for it installed. As such, this review will naturally be based on my experience with those patches being active. What all those patches do: replaces sprites and some backgrounds with the ones from the PS2 version, new text font, hides the interface menu buttons, brings back most of the music + sound effects that was removed/replaced in the MangaGamer version. By far the most important patches are the music and sound related ones, which I would recommend everyone to use. I'll explain why further down below in the "Sound/VA/Music" area.

 

Also, I highly recommend reading Higurashi with the typical horror setup; in the dark, alone, at night, with headphones (high volume), and with fullscreen mode on. Good immersion makes a tremendously positive difference, especially so for Ni. I can attest to that, hehe.

 

With that out of the way, let me tell you what Higurashi is all about!

 

 

 

Higurashi is a mystery thriller sound novel series. Yes, sound novel, because the music and sound effects majorly sets the tone of every scene for the reader, not so much the visuals. (I'll still call it a VN though, for simplicity's sake) The experience is certainly different compared to other VNs because of this. Your imagination becomes a much more important tool, not to mention your love for reading a great story in general. What is the story of Higurashi? Well, here's a basic version of its overview, which I did not write myself:

 

"Higurashi no Naku Koro ni takes place during June 1983, at a fictional rural village called Hinamizawa. The main character, Maebara Keiichi, moves to Hinamizawa and befriends his new classmates, Ryuuguu Rena, Sonozaki Mion, Furude Rika, and Houjou Satoko. Keiichi joins their after-school club activities, which consist mostly of card and board games (and punishment games for the loser, usually him.) Hinamizawa appears to be a normal, peaceful, rural village to Keiichi. However, the tranquility abruptly ends after the annual Watanagashi Festival, a celebration to commemorate and give thanks to the local god, Oyashiro-sama. Keiichi learns that every year for the past four years, one person has been murdered and another has gone missing on the day of the Watanagashi Festival. Keiichi himself soon becomes drawn into the strange events surrounding the Watanagashi Festival and Oyashiro-sama."

 

So, it's about a group of friends and the ominous mysteries that surround the seemingly peaceful and happy environment in which they live. Something very, very strange is going on. Again, that is as basic as you can get. But that's good. The less you know, the better. Simple information is all you should have before starting to read it, because I can promise you that it will be way more fun if you don't know too much about it beforehand. That's exactly how it was for me. In any case, Higurashi is magnificent when it comes to that pure mystery feeling. Not only that, it is also frequently worrying, tense and creepy, making you extremely paranoid about what's going on. These two traits, mystery and suspense, combines into what I like seeing in a VN the absolute most. And yes, Higurashi does it incredibly well, which is one of the reasons why I like it so much of course. You just can't stop thinking about the vast amount of well-crafted mysteries and problems that this brilliant story presents to you.

 

Based on what I've said so far, it probably sounds like Higurashi is all about the ominous mysteries and not much more. But that's not true at all. Trust me... there are many things about Higurashi that ultimately makes it a masterpiece. There are so many different feelings that you get from it at different times in all the eight arcs. For one, friendship plays a huge role in the story. There's plenty of light-hearted comedy and happy times to be had. It's not always "seriousface", and yes that's a good thing. You truly connect with the characters to a great extent over time, as well as get a sense of belonging in the setting in which the story takes place. Also, there's plenty of very emotional and tear-inducing scenes to be found in it, plus empowering ones that are just simply epic. And of course, many, many "What The Hell Is Going On?" moments. Higurashi has a bit of everything.

 

Oh, can't forget: Higurashi as a whole (arcs 1-8) is incredibly long. It took me over a hundred hours to get through, easily. This is a good thing though, because it means that the story can be very detailed and allows for great character development. It's a big plus for me personally.

 

Now for some more specific tidbits about this awesome mystery VN!

 

 

 


Visuals/Art - Not exactly an important part of Higurashi. The original PC novels were made so that music and sound effects would take precedence over visuals. You do have backgrounds and sprites, so sure, they can definitely strengthen the effect of certain scenes (...). In fact, I really like the PS2 sprites myself. They've got a pretty cute art style to them. The backgrounds are kinda nice too.

 

CGs? There are none in the original novels. However, if you use the PS2 sprite+background patch...well, who knows.

 

One thing I should tell you about is the text speed. Yes. The text speed itself can heighten the impact of a moment. Because you see, the speed of the text in Higurashi is not the same constantly. It sometimes changes depending on the situation. Are you reading something foreboding? Then the speed might get really slow... or fast. You may think this is a small thing - and it kinda is - but it certainly makes a difference. Not all VNs have this kind of effect. Since the text and the story it tells is so important for Higurashi, this is worth mentioning for sure.

 

Higurashi uses the NVL style - text is shown over the background and there's no dialog box present. Personally, I like this style a lot. I get more immersed in the story with it for some reason.

 

The system menus are simplistic but working. There's a fairly large amount of save slots available.

 

 

Sound/VA/Music - Very good music! And there's quite a large amount of different songs in total too, especially if we count both Ni and Kai together. This is necessary though I think, because the music in Higurashi is largely responsible for setting the mood in each scene, so you need many different songs for the many different situations. And guess what? It does it brilliantly. The (cheerful/sad/epic/ominous/gloomy/creepy) atmosphere is very, very good thanks to the music. In fact, I would daresay that every single song in there is memorable in some way, because they were all put in such great and fitting moments. That goes for happy songs, ominous songs, emotional songs, etc. All of it. It's nice to listen to outside of the VN as well, but mostly so after you've already went through a scene in which a particular song plays. Though there are some exceptions to this of course.

 

Sound effects also help strengthen the mood and atmosphere immensely, which was quite a surprise for me personally. It's remarkable just how much difference a simple sound effect can do when it plays at a perfect time. The same thing is true for music as well, in that the VN starts/stops songs perfectly depending on the situation.

 

Now you know why the music and sound patches are the most crucial to get! The more fitting music tracks and sound effects there are, the better. Seriously - you'll want those patches in particular!

 

It's important to note that Kai has much higher quality music in general. For one it just sounds clearer, but also, most of the songs are simply a lot more special and more awesome/beautiful than the ones found in Ni. Doesn't mean of course that the music in Ni is bad. But yea the OST in Kai is considerably better, for sure.

 

There's no voice acting in the original PC novels and there's no patch to "remedy" that. Normally I'd say that this is a weakness, but for Higurashi it's not really a huge deal to me. It would be cool to have, but that's all.

 

 

Characters - The characters and their development are VERY important for the overall story in Higurashi. They all have their own quirks and traits that makes them stand out from each other. To me, they are all likable and/or memorable and interesting. They are definitely a strong point for Higurashi. I love 'em!

 

The playing field sometimes changes a whole lot from arc to arc. I need to point that out especially because this is technically a double review, with both Ni and Kai. Therefore I won't go into too much detail at all about specific characters and their changes, importance, etc. But in any case, here are at least five main characters that MangaGamer decided to put up on their site:

 

Maebara Keiichi - The main protagonist in Higurashi. A charismatic and energetic guy who is good with words. In a lot of ways he's a very "typical" lead male character, but... he's good! I for one like him at least. He can be surprisingly funny at times.

 

Ryuuguu Rena - She's more or less the cover girl for Higurashi.

 

Sonozaki Mion - A tomboy class representative girl, who often calls herself "Uncle Mion". She leads the club activities that the group of friends partake in, and hands out (comical) punishments to the losers of those activities. She enjoys teasing others, but especially so Keiichi. She's great!

 

Houjou Satoko - The mischievous trap master girl. Yes. She tends to mess around with Keiichi a bunch, usually by making him fall into her silly but superbly set traps. I didn't like her as much as the others at start, but she definitely grew on me a lot over time. O ho ho ho!

 

Furude Rika - A silent, reasonable and intelligent little girl who likes to comfort people by patting them on the head. Everyone likes Rika! She's very adorable to say the least. Mi-... Nipa-*

 

Of course there are many more characters. Most of them are extremely crucial to the storyline itself too, just like the club members that I mentioned above are.

 

I need to stress once more that the playing field changes over time when it comes to the characters of Higurashi. Things do not always stay the same way. Keep that in mind, alright? And no, I'm not going to explain exactly what I mean by that. Just... keep it in mind anyway.

 

 

Plot/Story - Perfect! The number one thing that makes Higurashi a masterpiece. It has such an interesting, intricate and engrossing plot that, in the end, any "negatives" that the VN might have are absolutely meaningless because of it. Yes, that's how good it is. I got absolutely swallowed up by it myself. This is at the very top for me, as far as storylines go. It blends several elements really well, such as suspense, comedy, emotional moments (it has successfully made me teary-eyed and even cry more than once), action, mystery, and more. Of course, what you get and how much you get of each element varies a lot depending on which arc you happen to be on...

 

As I've said before, Higurashi consists of two VNs, Ni and Kai. Ni contains the questions arcs 1-4. This is the first part of the series. These arcs are called "questions arcs" because they are the ones that will introduce you to Hinamizawa and the immense amount of mysterious problems surrounding this rural village. You become familiar with the environment and the various characters while reading through these arcs, while at the same time, the mysteries continue to pile up more and more. And let me tell you... it is so much fun. You get plenty of opportunities to think and ponder about all of it, which is very much deliberate. That's what these arcs are meant for. The paranoia that you experience in these arcs is goddamn immense - borderline overwhelming. I'm serious. Take your sweet time to form your opinions and theories about what is happening in Hinamizawa, and then move on to answer arcs 5-8 in Kai.

 

Kai is the second and final part of Higurashi. It contains the answer arcs 5-8. They are called "answer arcs" because many answers are given to the numerous mysteries in these arcs, but some new mysteries are also presented at the same time. I admit that I was first worried about Kai not being as interesting or fun as Ni, and yet, I ended up loving it even more than Ni. Unexpected, to be honest. It may or may not be the same for you when you decide to read Higurashi. I can't really talk too much about Kai though. But it is the grand finale to the story that is already excellent from the very beginning. And an epic finale it is indeed.

 

All arcs in Higurashi are excellent. There is not even a single arc that feels "weak". Sure, some arcs are a bit better and more powerful/meaningful than others, but none of them are bad or boring in some way. At least they weren't for me. Each arc has several things that makes it special and important. So in a way, the entirety of Higurashi is entertaining from start to finish, and that's certainly quite a feat considering the length of the series.

 

Have you watched the anime of Higurashi but not read the VN? That's a bit unfortunate if that's the case. Now, from what I have heard and seen so far, the anime is not bad. It's decent/good. But still, what I can tell you for sure is that the story in the VN is far more detailed. Plus the mystery feeling that you get from it is miiiiles better than what you get from the anime. So if you have not been spoiled by the anime already, then you should be happy about that fact and go read the VN right now!

 

No walkthroughs or route orders are needed. No significant choices are made in Higurashi, and so it actually counts as a series of kinetic novels as well. That said, you often reach checkpoints of sorts while reading. When you reach a checkpoint, you almost always get the opportunity to read so-called "TIPS". TIPS are basically small scenes and moments in which you receive details and extra information about a wide variety of things. It could be a page from a notebook/diary that someone is writing, or a conversation between two characters about something in particular, etc. It's quite a unique extra feature that comes with Higurashi, and yea, I like it a lot.

 

Also, after finishing an arc you get access to the "Scenario Jump Mode" for that specific arc. With that you can jump to any day you want on that arc, if you feel like re-reading a certain part of it or something.

 

There are other extra features as well... oh yes, there are some nice surprises to be had. But I think they should remain surprises too!

 

 

Screenshots (click the thumbnails) -

 

Higu-1.jpg Higu-2.jpg Higu-3.jpg Higu-4.jpg Higu-5.jpg Higu-6.jpg Higu-7.jpg Higu-8.jpg

Higu-9.jpg Higu-10.png Higu-11.jpg Higu-12.jpg Higu-13.jpg Higu-14.jpg Higu-15.jpg Higu-16.jpg

Higu-Y.jpg

 


 

 

 

Final words - Oh man, in case it hasn't been obvious enough already - I LOVE HIGURASHI. Everything about it. The series as a whole is more or less legendary to me now after finishing it. Hinamizawa itself is an amazing setting that I will never forget. Neither will I forget all the awesome characters, or the wonderful music that fits in extremely well with all the memorable moments. I did not expect to like it this much really, yet that's exactly how it ended up in any case. But I guess it's not too strange though, considering that the story itself is of the mystery variant. It's just that Higurashi manages to handle all those numerous mysteries plus everything else so frikkin' well. And as such it's just perfect for me. Higurashi frightened me, made me cry, made me paranoid, made me despair, made me happy, made me laugh... and much more.

 

Would you enjoy it as much as I did? Possibly! Do you prefer an amazing story and great characters more than anything else in a VN? Then Higurashi is definitely for you. Even better if you like mystery stories. In fact, if you have the same preferences as me, then there's a good chance that it will even become a favourite of yours in the end.

 

Higurashi no Naku Koro ni - READ IT. Both Ni and Kai!

 

 

Pros: Lengthy, amazingly well-written overall plot, massive amount of mysteries, awesome atmosphere, good suspense and sense of mystery, unforgettable characters, excellent and fitting background music and sound effects, terrific handling of music+sound, TIPS system + other nice extras, Hinamizawa itself (my #1 favourite setting in any VN so far), good variety and amount of special and memorable moments, all arcs are great (= entertaining from start to finish.)

 

Cons: No voice acting (would just be a bonus to have though as an OPTION, nothing more)

 

 

 

Harlequin gives Higurashi no Naku Koro ni a rating of...

9.8/10

(Follows the rating scale on VNDB)

 

 

... and Higurashi no Naku Koro ni Kai a rating of...

 

 

10/10

(Follows the rating scale on VNDB)

 

Remember, this is only my opinion and experience with these visual novels.

 

 

 

 

Here's the spoiler box with some spoilerish thoughts and impressions I got from reading Higurashi.

Do not touch it if you have not fully read ALL of Higurashi (Ni+Kai) already:

 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Edited by Harlequin
Link to post
Share on other sites

Still very surprised you liked it this much. I thought you would like it but a 10/10 never would have imagined you would like it this much. VERY VERY glad to see, probably your best review so far imo.

 

Not sure if you know but one of the reasons why Higurashi Kai has better music is because since Ryukishi was just middle class with Ni he actually could only use only free non copyright music online. (The only people who also worked on Ni were his brother, himself, and his mother and father did advertising). Most stores wouldnt even carry his game because he was a nobody. But once Ni became popular after it spread online then it started selling very well so he was able to spend more money on Kai.

 

Edit- Forgot to add which lead to Kai's success and then when Umineko was released at C72 it sold out in 30 minutes because Ryukishi would never have imagined it would be that popular.

 

Also needed to add that the music in Kai was done by fans of Ryukishi who sent him music, Dai being the most influential as most of his music is in the game.

Edited by battlerrules
Link to post
Share on other sites
  battlerrules said:
Not sure if you know but one of the reasons why Higurashi Kai has better music is because since Ryukishi was just middle class with Ni he actually could only use only free non copyright music online.

 

Now THAT... I was not aware of. Remarkable. He sure as hell picked some incredibly fitting music for this story then, seriously. It sounds great because it fits so well with each scene in there. But sure, it's definitely not as great as the music from Dai in Kai. That's one of the reasons why Kai was even better than Ni for me by the way.

 

  battlerrules said:
when Umineko was released at C72 it sold out in 30 minutes

 

Oh yea, read about that some days ago actually... kinda crazy. Well I'm very happy that he's doing so well now. He deserves it.

Edited by Harlequin
Link to post
Share on other sites

Since I can't really add anything more to the first post (character limit reached), have to do it like this...

 

 

A cool little present for those who have finished Higurashi completely (don't open unless that is true for you):

 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

 

 

I've put together a complete package of Higurashi!

 

This is EXACTLY what you need if you feel like reading Higurashi with as many patches applied as possible:

 

 

 

Higurashi - When They Cry COMPLETE

 

All arcs (1-8), all patches, working.

 

Fully updated as of - 20th of February 2013.

 

part 1 - part 2 - part 3 - part 4 - part 5 - part 6

 

Check the README.txt

 

EDIT: http://higurashifix.wikia.com/wiki/Translation_Patches was fairly recently added to the Higurashi tweak site. I personally do not know how good/bad this patch is right now. Supposedly it fixes some grammar and spelling of the MangaGamer translation for the first 1-4 arcs of Higurashi. This patch is currently not in my pack of the game, so if you want to download and use it you can do so with that link. To use it: Extract all of the files to the arc 1-4 game folder.

Edited by Harlequin
translation patch notice
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 11 months later...

This novel was absolutely amazing. I can't believe how much was done with so little. You are an awesome person for recommending this one Harle it was a masterpiece.

 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

I only hope I can read more novels like this one in the future. I hear that Umineko is supposed to be really great so I am going to try that one next. I have purposefully not read anything about it so I don't even know the basic premise of it and I only have opinions of others to go on. If it is anything like Higurashi I already know it is going to be amazing too.

Link to post
Share on other sites

you did well, there are two or three spoiles that can really ruin the game.

 

About higurashi, that game has an evil curse, i keep telling my self i was only goint to read until the next checkpoint and when i come back to my self 4 hours passed and i was around half of the story. Like pringles, you cant just read a little.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 weeks later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...